In October, Headway asked for perpetual rights to your name, your likeness, and your voice. You pushed back. They paused it within a day. About 180 of you came to a town hall to talk it through.
The new agreement dropped November 18. Three documents: a Provider Agreement, Platform Terms of Service, and a separate Arbitration Agreement. Sign by February 17.
Now ask yourself one question while you read this: what would convince you this is the best move for your practice?
You're not signing with Headway
The agreement says it in plain text: "Headway is not a party to this Agreement."
Your contract is with "the Practice," a set of professional corporations that hold the insurance contracts and bill for your sessions. One person signs for all of them.
November finally names them: three corporations in each of nine states. Your state not one of the nine? The documents never tell you who you're signing with. Your state on the list? The text still doesn't say which of the three is yours. To know what business you're actually in a contract with, you'd have to go look up the corporations in your state yourself.
Headway's legal name is Therapymatch, Inc. It runs the platform, the billing, the credentialing, the marketing. It's just not a party to your contract.
Now do the math on what each side risks
Headway's liability to you: $100. That's the cap, in writing (Platform Terms, Section 8.3). Everything you've invested, the time, the money, the caseload you built. If they fail you, their total exposure is a hundred dollars.
Your exposure to them: whatever they claw back. They can't take more than they paid you on a claim, and the extrapolated clawbacks are gone. But the policy that governs clawbacks is not in your contract. It lives in the portal, it controls over the agreement when the two conflict (10.6), and it can be updated by posting it (10.2). Your rates can't change without your signature. The clawback policy can.
Your clinical records: the license never ends. Section 7.5(a) gives the Practice and Headway a perpetual, irrevocable, royalty-free license to store, use, retain, and disclose your records, including for "operating and improving the Platform's tools and features." The records stay your legal responsibility (7.5(c)). Your duty never ends. Their license never ends. When the agreement ends, you get 90 days to download what's on the platform (7.5(d)). Then the window closes.
Your clients: if a client found you in their insurance plan's provider directory, they count as a Marketplace Patient (5.1(c)). Never saw a Headway page. Doesn't matter. When you leave, the 12-month non-solicit (5.8) covers them. You can tell them you're leaving. You can't tell them they can keep seeing you.
Your voice: fixed, and read it closely. Section 6.4 promises no digital replica of you: no AI avatar, no synthetic voice, no chatbot pretending to be you. A composite built from thousands of therapists is not a replica of you. That door is still open, and 7.5 is where the raw material lives.
What they got right
The likeness clause is gone. Indemnification runs both ways again (9.2). No extrapolated clawbacks. Recoupment capped at what they paid (4.3). And you can opt out of arbitration with one message to provider support, as long as you send it within 30 days of signing.
That happened because therapists read the contract in October and refused to sign blind. It worked. Don't forget that part.
Before you sign
You have until February 17. Nothing pays you to sign early.
Read the text, not the friendly explainer boxes. The documents say the boxes are not terms and the text wins (10.8).
Ask Headway in writing, and keep the answers: Which Practice entity am I contracting with in my state? Do clients who found me in an insurance directory trigger the $9.99 Marketplace fee? Where is the current Clawback Protection Policy, and how will I be told when it changes? If I leave, what format does my records export come in?
If you sign, send the arbitration opt-out in the same sitting. Thirty days goes fast.
I'm not a lawyer and this isn't legal advice. I'm a therapist who reads contracts before he signs them. Two breakdowns are worth your time: Therapist Daily Brief's section-by-section read and Therapy Is a Business on what changed.
So I'll ask it one more time. What would convince you this is the best move for you?
Private pay isn't a dream. It's a decision. Make it with your eyes open.
DJ
